Wow, some interesting contrasts there. For me some of Gilliams choices seem rather weak - mainly because of Robin Williams as Rorscach, that is the stupid thing ive ever heard.
Mind you Akerman or Swank that is very interesting, Akerman looks the part but does not do the part too well. Im in two minds for this one.
Patrick Wilson and Morgan are spot on in my eyes. Though Either of the comedian suggestions could actually work in my eyes.
Jude Law and Paddy C. could have worked too. Goode delivers a good performance the odd time throughout the film he has a certain degree of ice heartedness about him. As for Paddy C. im a fan of him in general but Haley IS Rorschach.